The Systemic Hierarchy of “Human” & Its Creation of the Animalized Woman and Sexualized/Feminized Animal

Carol J. Adams is a feminist-vegan advocate and activist whose work is not only influential but groundbreaking in her vision.

Philosophical activist Lisa Kemmerer put it best when she said Adams “unfolds her grizzly discoveries with a wry sense of humor, and sends readers out into the world with a fresh vision—a vision that pierces through the images on the magazine rack, in the frozen meat section of the grocery store, on billboards, or in television advertisements. Adams’ work heightens awareness, shifts thinking, and has the power to alter behavior…” (Kemmerer). 

And that’s exactly how I felt after reading her interview and editorial piece, “The War on Compassion,” in Antennae Project’s The Politics of Meat issue—altered. Once Adams peels back the curtain to expose the damaging way in which our patriarchal society categorizes everything around us through intrinsically oppressive systemic hierarchies, there’s no un-seeing or un-knowing it. 

Adams emphasizes that under our current mode of thinking, “We are human animals; they, those we view as not-us, are nonhuman animals” (5). And, “as long as the definition exists through negation…the inscription of ‘human’…accepts that there is something fixed about humanness which we can establish ‘humans’ possess, and importantly, that others do not possess” (5). By causing a split, or differentiation between categories, a hierarchy is inherently created. We’ve seen it all before—dehumanizing racism and genocide. But what about those who aren’t deemed ‘human’ to begin with? 

That’s when we’re left with speciesism. “Speciesism has always been a toll of colonialism: creating a hierarchy of color and characteristics” (Adams 8). Under speciesism, instead of genocide, it’s meat-eating and hunting. Adams notes that “The latter is normalized violence [and] normalized violence disowns compassion” (5). 

Consider the term “dehumanizing” itself—it denotes humanness is a quality that can be stripped away by oppression. And what’s left in the absence of humanness? Animal. Why do we relegate lesser value to the term “animal”? Adams opened my eyes when she wrote, “When people say, They treated us like animals…they are saying They treated us as though we had no feelings, as though we were not alive…they mean, I was reduced to literal existence, I could not do, I was done to” (7). Why would we ever subject another living being to that kind of violence?

Why have we pedestalled “humanness” above the needs of other living beings and the Earth itself? And why must we continue to climb the patriarchal hierarchy by relegating those who do not fit into the androcentric Anglo-European patriarchal mold —like women, people of color, gender-con-conforming individuals, or those who don’t conform to perpetuated heterosexual norms—to the status of animals, another oppressed group by a different name. I have to agree with Adams when she argues, “Human society takes from the oppression of animals its structures and treatment of other humans…All originating forms of oppression can be traced to our treatment of animals. Domestication became the pattern from social subordination; predation the pattern for killing and extermination” (Adams 8).

Adams reveals this innate link of oppression and its prevalence in our daily lives through everyday images that highlight the women-animal or women-nature connection that patriarchal hegemony has underscored society with. The following images are ones Adams has collected on her website

In this image, the caption reads, “It’s not acceptable to treat a woman like one.” It’s not a false statement, but why are we ignoring the big picture here? It’s not acceptable to treat anyone like this—slaughtered for human consumption and desire—skinned and exposed—pierced through the flesh to hang on a hook. The ad cannot even bear to identify “the animal” by name. Adams notes that “the most efficient way to insure that humans do not care about the lives of animals is to transform nonhuman subjects into nonhuman objects” (Adams 6). Adams defines this as “massification” (6) when we strip animals of their individual identities through terms like ‘meat’ or, in the case of this ad ‘one’ as a means to alleviate empathy. “When nonhuman living beings are converted conceptually into false mass terms to enable their conversion into products, we come to believe that their deaths do not matter to themselves. Animals are killed because they are false mass terms, but they die as individuals. They die as a cow, not beef, as a pig, not pork. Each suffers his or her own death, and this death matters a great deal to the one who is dying” (Adams 7). Even as this ad tries to do good by drawing attention to the way that women not treated as equals to men, it unknowingly also reveals the inherent hierarchical thinking that places women, like animals, beneath fair treatment deserving of white, cis-heterosexual men. 

This image acknowledges the hardship involved in raising/supporting a child while navigating life as a single mother. It acknowledges the disadvantaged position of women, but it does so by equating it with beheading. The usual phrase, “I’m running around like a chicken with its head cut off,” is a much more violent and disturbing image that we use colloquially every day. Does the working single mother face extra burdens and obstacles via her disadvantaged placement in our systemically hierarchical society? Yes, undoubtedly. Is that as extreme as a beheading? Look at the parallels between women and the hen, women, and animals. The working single mother has been consumed by the desires of man and then tossed away once inconvenient, the same way that a “working” hen’s life is devolved to forced reproduction and eventual consumption at the hands of man’s hunger and desire. It’s a picture all to familiar and a connection that’s too apparent to dismiss. 

And now, consider the “world’s manliest sandwich.” What is it that makes this sandwich different than other sandwiches that will set this one as decidedly more masculine? Obviously, it’s the lack of a bun. “Meat eating is associated with virility, masculinity” (Potts 13). In the bun’s place are two pieces of chicken. The entire sandwich is a picture of domination. And as we all (unfortunately) know, domination = manly. It’s a meat on meat on meat sandwich. Slaughted chicken for a bun. Slaughted pig for the filling. Cheese is a product of forced, unceasing breeding to keep cows in an eternal state of reproduction to commodify their milk. Down to the mayo that’s made of egg yolks. The whole sandwich screams violence and oppression, and yet we look at that and say, “Wow! That’s a manly sandwich!” It only goes to show how deeply ingrained toxic masculinity and hierarchical oppression goes–to the very foundation of our thinking, to the bedrock of society. 

In the ever-cyclical “process of objectification/fragmentation/consumption [that] connects women and animals in a patriarchal culture…women are animalized, and animals are sexualized and feminized” (Potts 13). You see it all around us in the images above, in the other snapshots captured and displayed on Carol J Adam’s website, and even in children’s television shows… take a second look at Miss Piggy. I want to finish off this post with another image to contemplate —I wish I could say “a final image,” but the truth is, you’ll continue to notice the constant exposure of the animalized woman and sexualized animal paradigm in tv-ads, billboards, menu signs, food labels, grocery stores, etc., etc., etc. around you. 

I used to work at a bookstore, and as a result, I’m no stranger to the Fifty Shades of Grey craze. I’m all for women exploring their sexuality and honoring their pleasure, and if giving up all control to a dominating person does that for someone, I’m not here to judge. However, this parody cookbook just didn’t sit right with me…and now, after being exposed to Adams’ insights, I know why.

“‘Consumable’ animals are invariably portrayed as feminine, as sexual–available to men, just like female human beings” (Kemmerer). A chicken–a living, breathing individual–was slaughtered, and its dead body was bound and posed to convey enticement, that the chicken wanted this and wants you to consume it, ravish it. In Lisa Kemmerer’s overview of Carol J Adams’ The Pornography of Meat, she included a quote from Adams that sums up the debasement captured in this image, “Meat is like pornography before it was someone’s fun, it was someone’s life.”

Here’s the trailer for the cookbook. An initial viewing might find it humorous, as parodies are meant to be. But now, it’s impossible to un-see the violation of a corpse—a feminized, sexualized, dehumanized corpse—that is trussed up and displayed for what? Privileged human desire. All-encompassing human consumption. 

———

I’m interested to know your thoughts on the women-animal-consumer-consumed paradigm. Has Carol J. Adams altered your thinking? Do you notice similar images propagandized around us? What do you see as a way forward or away from the current systemic hierarchy we find ourselves amidst?

Works Cited

Adams, Carol J. “The War on Compassion.” Antennae, no. 14, 2010, pp. 5–11., static1.squarespace.com/static/54792ff7e4b0674c74cb719d/t/55dc8dace4b0ad76d7277cb7/1440517548517/ANTENNAE+ISSUE+14.pdf. Accessed 10 Mar. 2023. 

Kemmerer, Lisa. “The Pornography of Meat by Carol Adams.” Philosophy Now: A Magazine of Deas, Philosophy Now, 2006, philosophynow.org/issues/56/The_Pornography_of_Meat_by_Carol_Adams. 

Potts, Annie and Adams, Carol J. “The Politics of Carol J. Adams.” Antennae, no. 14, 2010, pp. 12–24., static1.squarespace.com/static/54792ff7e4b0674c74cb719d/t/55dc8dace4b0ad76d7277cb7/1440517548517/ANTENNAE+ISSUE+14.pdf. Accessed 10 Mar. 2023. 

 

1,329 Replies to “The Systemic Hierarchy of “Human” & Its Creation of the Animalized Woman and Sexualized/Feminized Animal”

  1. บทความนี้เกี่ยวกับพวงหรีดดอกไม้ มีสาระมาก
    การรู้ว่าดอกไม้แต่ละชนิดมีความหมายอย่างไร ช่วยให้เลือกได้ตรงความรู้สึกมากขึ้น
    จะบอกต่อให้เพื่อนๆ ที่ต้องการเลือกดอกไม้ไปงานศพอ่านด้วย

    Here is my website; แพ็กเกจจัดงานศพ

  2. Howdy! I’m at work browsing your blog from my new
    iphone 4! Just wanted to say I love reading your blog and look forward to all your posts!
    Keep up the fantastic work!

  3. Good day! This post couldn’t be written any better!
    Reading through this post reminds me of my good old room mate!
    He always kept talking about this. I will forward this write-up
    to him. Fairly certain he will have a good
    read. Many thanks for sharing!

  4. I every time used to study post in news papers but now as I am a
    user of web thus from now I am using net for articles
    or reviews, thanks to web.

  5. Найти официальные сайты интернет магазинов больше не составит и оплата: вам лишь требуется сделать
    категорией продукции и наша.

    my site – shoesprice.ru

  6. Good day! Would you mind if I share your blog with my facebook group?
    There’s a lot of folks that I think would really appreciate your content.
    Please let me know. Thank you

  7. Wow, wonderful blog layout! How lengthy have you been running a blog
    for? you made running a blog glance easy. The total glance of your site
    is great, let alone the content!

  8. Wow, a reputable Junior College гemains fantastic, howeᴠer maths serves as the king subject therе, cultivating logical cognition whiϲh sets yοur kid ready
    foг O-Level success аnd beyond.

    Victoria Junior College cultivates creativity ɑnd management, igniting enthusiasms for
    future production. Coastal campus facilities support arts, humanities,
    аnd sciences. Integrated programs ᴡith alliances սse seamless,
    enriched education. Service аnd international initiatives develop caring, resistant people.
    Graduates lead ԝith conviction, accomplishing exceptional success.

    Eunoia Junior College embodies tһe peak of modern educational innovation, housed іn a striking һigh-rise school
    that effortlessly integrates common learning ɑreas, green arеaѕ, аnd advanced technological hubs to
    develop an motivating atmosphere fօr collaborative and experiential education. Тһe college’s unique
    approach of ” lovely thinking” encourages trainees tօ blend intellectual
    iinterest ᴡith generosity and ethical thinking, supported ƅy vibrant scholastic programs іn the arts, sciences, ɑnd interdisciplinary studies tһat promote creative analytical аnd forward-thinking.

    Equipped ԝith tоp-tier facilities ѕuch as professional-grade performing arts theaters, multimedia studios,
    ɑnd interactive science laboratories, trainees аrе empowered to
    pursue thеir passions and establish exceptional talents
    іn a holistic manner. Ƭhrough strategic collaborations ᴡith leading universities ɑnd industry leaders, tһе college ᧐ffers enhancing chances for
    undergraduate-level гesearch, internships, ɑnd mentorship tһɑt
    bridge class knowing with real-ѡorld applications.
    Αѕ a result, Eunoia Junior College’s trainees progress іnto thoughtful,
    resistant leaders ԝho arе not only academically accomplished Ьut also deeply devoted tߋ contributing positrively to a varied and ever-evolving global society.

    Aiyo, lacking robust math ɗuring Junior College, еѵen toр institution children might falter ѡith
    high school algebra, tһerefore build thіs immedіately leh.

    Oi oi, Singapore folks, maths гemains likely the
    extremely іmportant primary subject, fostering innovation fоr issue-resolving tо groundbreaking careers.

    Вesides t᧐ school facilities, focus սpon mathematics tо avoiⅾ typical errors
    including sloppy mistakes іn exams.

    Aiyo, wіthout robust math ɑt Junior College, regardlesѕ t᧐p school
    kids migһt falter at next-level equations, tһus build tһat immediately
    leh.
    Listen ᥙp, Singapore moms ɑnd dads, maths is probɑbly the
    highly crucial primary subject, encouraging imagination tһrough issue-resolving to groundbreaking careers.

    Kiasu students ѡho excel in Math Ꭺ-levels oftеn land overseas scholarships tⲟo.

    Ꭰon’t tаke lightly lah, link а excellent Junior College alongside maths excellence іn oгder to ensure
    elevated A Levels гesults as wеll аs seamless changes.

    Ꭺlso visit my blog post: Ahmad Ibrahim Secondary School

  9. BJ38 한국에서 플레이하고 최고의
    온라인 도박 경험을 즐기세요: 슬롯, 라이브 카지노, 스포츠북, 그리고 매일 풍성한 보너스가 제공됩니다.

  10. Hi there! Quick question that’s entirely off topic. Do you know how to make
    your site mobile friendly? My website looks weird when browsing from
    my iphone 4. I’m trying to find a theme or plugin that might
    be able to correct this problem. If you have any suggestions, please share.

    Thank you!

  11. Hello, Neat post. There is a problem with your site in web
    explorer, might check this? IE still is the market chief and
    a huge portion of folks will pass over your excellent writing because of this problem.

  12. Предпочтение отдаётся металлическим оттенкам,
    тёмно-зелёному, чёрному, тёмно-синим цветам.

    Also visit my homepage :: maax-mebel.ru

  13. I do not even know the way I stopped up here,
    however I believed this publish used to be great.

    I do not know who you’re however definitely you’re going to a
    well-known blogger in the event you are not already.
    Cheers!

  14. First off I want to say terrific blog! I had a quick question in which I’d like to ask if you don’t
    mind. I was curious to find out how you center yourself and clear your mind prior to
    writing. I have had a hard time clearing my mind in getting my thoughts out.
    I truly do enjoy writing however it just seems like
    the first 10 to 15 minutes are usually wasted simply just trying to figure out how to begin. Any ideas or tips?
    Many thanks!

  15. Kaizenaire.com leads Singapore’ѕ promotions witһ unsurpassable deals and deals.

    Singapore’s global popularity аs a shopping location іs driven bү Singaporeans’ undeviating love fߋr promotions and savings.

    Singaporeans oftеn participate in digital photography walks t᧐ record tһe
    city’s sensational sky line,and bear in mind tⲟ stay updated
    on Singapore’ѕ mоst гecent promotions and shopping
    deals.

    Haidilao supplies hotpot dining experiences ѡith exceptional solution, adored ƅy Singaporeans fоr thеir savory broths
    аnd interactive dishes.

    SK Jewellery crafts ɡreat gold and diamond items mah,
    treasured Ьy Singaporeans for thеir beautiful designs thгoughout cheery celebrations ѕia.

    Suntory freshens witһ teas and waters, preferred for premium Japanese drinks іn benefit stores.

    Кeep tabs sia, on the most ᥙр to dаte
    from Kaizenaire.com lor.

    Here is my blog post – promotions singapore

  16. наш ресурс «Каталог Магазинов»
    создан для удобства поиска любом интернет-магазинов по темам товаров – найти список магазинов какие.

    Here is my web site: http://shop21vek.ru

  17. Hi there, i read your blog occasionally and i own a similar one
    and i was just wondering if you get a lot of spam remarks?
    If so how do you reduce it, any plugin or anything you can suggest?
    I get so much lately it’s driving me crazy so any assistance is very much appreciated.

  18. Hello! I’ve been following your website for
    a long time now and finally got the courage to go ahead and
    give you a shout out from Humble Texas!

    Just wanted to mention keep up the fantastic job!

  19. Explore Kaizenaire.ai, an ingenious Singapore recruitment agency concentrated ߋn fuⅼl-time talent
    from the Philippines, ρowered bʏ AI chatbots to manage multi-platform questions ɑnd leads.

    In Singapore’ѕ context օf expensive labor and escalating concerns, іt’s a сomplete company benefit tо
    contract out to overseas employees from the Philippines, cutting 70% fгom perpetual costs.
    Ԝith ᎪI, efficiency matches locals.

    Ꮲrovided AI technologies tοday and dismal climate, magnate іn Singapore mᥙѕt immеdiately evaluate tһeir
    existing frameworks and workflows, embracing
    АI automation гight awaү t᧐ sustain rivalry. Additionally, АI’s development is at fulⅼ throttle.

    Functioning as a trusted Singapore recruitment agency, Kaizenaire concentrates оn supporting Singapore business tо hire creative talent from the Philippines, wіth ΑI tools allowing remote designers tߋ craft blog site content
    and carry out social media marketing.

    Νow iѕ the time to reassess thе synergy of AI and remote employees іn future business operating.
    Introducing Kaizenaire– Singapore’ѕ innovative recruitment agency fⲟr remote hiring solutions.

    mʏ web-site … Singapore AI Chatbot

Leave a Reply to Ahmad Ibrahim Secondary School Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *